Seems a little unfair, doesn’t it?
It occurs for a variety of reasons, most of which are not technical and relate to the main four SEO success principals of:
I call this the Wikipedia effect, which I explain further in a bit.
Sites with More Content Rank Higher
If you’re trying to outrank a well-established competitor whose website has 2,000 pages because they’ve been publishing consistently for 3 years, it’s going to take you some time.
Sites That are Updated More Often Rank Higher
Does your competitor update their site daily whereas you update your site weekly? One of the key factors in the ranking is to update your site consistently and frequently.
Sites That are Old Rank Higher
And there is nothing you can do about this except to keep on keeping on. In time your website will be older. Additionally, as you publish more and more stuff your site will rank for a wider range of keyword phrases as it will contain content on a wider range of topics.
The Wikipedia Effect
No matter what you search for, a page on Wikipedia shows on the first page. Usually quite high on the first page.
This is because Wikipedia is a very large repository of very good content that is updated very often and has been around for 10 years.
The closer your website comes to that idea within your niche, the higher it will rank. This is also the reason news websites tend to consistently outrank business blogs.
There are Some Technical Reasons Too
A small website that is updated infrequently will rank high when it has high-value backlinks. High-value backlinks come from high-value pages. If you’re lucky enough for your business to have been written up in the New York Times, or Fox News, or Huffington Post, etc and to have received a backlink or two as a result, your search ranking will be raised. Sometimes significantly.
This is where your blog posts link to each other. When you do this well you increase the search ranking of specific pages on your site (the ones linked to the most).
Really Useful Content
Let’s say your site has the best most easily used mortgage calculator page on the Internet. Word will get out and people looking for mortgages will slow show up.
Note here the focus is not on quality per se, but on usefulness. Google, in fact, defines quality as usefulness.
The more useful a webpage is, the higher it’s quality and the higher its ranking.
It also helps that very useful pages tend to attract quality backlinks.SEO Needs Link Building